A Surging Virus, Wirecard & The Over-Profitable – Opportunities Are Appearing

This week we take a look at some of our current (and former) portfolio holdings and the impact recent developments both here and overseas have had on their prospects going forward, we see potential as future opportunities for investors.

Authors: Ron Shamgar

US Virus Outbreak/Surge

The US Covid-19 outbreak has, in the last few weeks, accelerated again and seen record new case numbers reported in the last few days. On Saturday alone, over 40,000 new cases were reported. This takes the total (official) cases since this started to 2.5m. The recent surges are being experienced primarily in the southern states of California, Arizona, Nevada, Florida and Texas.

Several of these states are now pulling back on their reopening plans, in some cases reinstating shutdowns for bars and other venues. Although we don’t see lockdowns being reinstated in full, it is our job to look for opportunities and we do think this trend is a positive for both Pushpay Holdings (PPH.ASX) and Marley Spoon (MMM.ASX).


PPH is a payment company enabling mobile app donations to the faith giving sector in the US. The business services over 10,000 churches and has seen a marked increase in take up as church goers stay home but still wish to connect and support their local community church. A recent profit upgrade by PPH reaffirms this trend with $74m EBITDA guidance for FY21. We expect the company to continue to grow, benefiting from this structural shift, and exceed $110m in EBITDA within two years. Given this, we think the stock could be worth in excess of $10.00.

Marley Spoon (MMM) is an online meal kit subscription business enabling consumers to order fresh ingredients according to easy to make recipes and portions to cook at home. We already saw the company benefit immensely during the lockdown period as people stayed at home and took up their services. Since then there were some concerns that growth could taper off as restrictions eased. The recent local outbreaks and the company having good exposure to the surging US market plays neatly into their outlook for at least this year. We expect a strong and profitable quarterly update in the next couple of weeks. MMM is currently trading at about half the revenue multiple of their larger peer, Hellofresh.


Wirecard’s Collapse Creates an Opportunity

Last week one of the world’s largest payment companies and a DAX top 30 German listed stock, Wirecard, was found to be trading fraudulently. Their CEO was arrested, and the business was placed into administration. The news rocked the fintech industry across Europe and the US.

​For perspective: Wirecard reported (in Euros) about $2.8bn revenue and $800m EBITDA in CY2019.
Over the weekend the UK financial regulator has suspended the accounts of many of Wirecard’s digital banking customers (Pockit, Curve, Anna Money, among others) in order to protect customer funds. This has seen these providers scrambling to look for alternative and credible issuers to manage their customer programs. We believe EML Payments (EML.ASX), through its acquisition of PFS, could benefit immensely from this monumental customer churn event. Our estimates and analysis indicate an opportunity of up to $50m of revenue for EML is up for grabs in the next few months. Watch this space, execution will be key. We value EML at over $4.00.

Too Profitable? There’s a Downside

Lastly, this week Jumbo Interactive (JIN.ASX) updated the market on a renegotiated lottery ticket reseller agreement with Tabcorp (TAH.ASX). The agreement, due to expire in 2023, will now be extended to 2030 for a one-off fee of $15m. Unfortunately, the new agreement incorporates a new service fee that will phase in gradually from FY21 to FY24 and will see JIN pay an additional 4.65% of its lottery ticket sales back to TAH. We estimate this to represent a revenue hit of $28m by 2023, all lost profit for JIN.

For JIN holders this agreement is bittersweet news. It secured longevity but gives away significant margin. We wrote about JIN previously and took our position at around $9.00 about three months ago as we saw online lotteries to be a pure beneficiary from the unfolding Covid-19 situation. The stock then appreciated to $14.00 and we sold down the vast majority of our holding as our valuation of $13.00+ was exceeded. The recent update indicates that the trend toward online lotteries continues to accelerate. But, with JIN being too good at doing so and earning close to 60% EBITDA margins, it was probably never sustainable selling a product that is licensed to someone else.

Over time we expect the charity lottery business here and overseas to diversify sales away from Tabcorp. With the shift to online lotto sales only growing, we still see profits growing but at a lower rate, as the phased in service fee kicks in over time. We will continue to monitor JIN and potentially look for an opportunity to re-enter the stock as investor sentiment and enthusiasm inevitably dampens.

Talking 2 Top Telcos | Part 2

There’s an old saying that in a mining boom, investors should buy the companies supplying the picks and shovels. This week we present part 2 of our examination of the telco sector; we take a look at a services provider to the sector and see how it is benefiting from the surge in demand for connectivity that has been accelerated by the WFH trend.
​Service Stream (SSM.ASX) provides services for Australia’s telecommunications, gas, electricity and water utilities, with large blue-chip clients including the likes of NBN Co, Telstra and a number of network owners and operators in the Australian water and energy sectors. Services provided include network design & construction, utility meter reading, replacement & installation, and the design & repair of utility assets, such as water pipelines, through the recent acquisition of Comdain.

Source: SSM company filings

We estimate that about 50% of SSM’s revenue is represented by NBN Co and Telstra. In FY19, NBN Co represented $463m of group revenue, while Telstra delivered $97m in revenue. Although in many cases the concentration of two large customers presents a risk, we believe strong demand for network connections and 5G mobile upgrades will see continued work for SSM for the next few years.

Recently NBN has recorded significant increases in the amount of traffic across its network (download traffic on 24 April at 11am was 62% above pre-COVID19 levels, upstream usage was up 117%). This is a result of individuals being forced to work from home and thus the increased use of technology like video conferencing and streaming. While this particular spike in demand is short-term, it is an acceleration of a longer term trend of increasing demand in the connectivity space as more and more aspects of our lives move online.

NBN has also revealed that activations rose 32% in March from their February levels. The 176k new premises activated in March was the highest monthly number since August 2019. In addition, SSM may also see a tailwind from further NBN maintenance & assurance activities, due to increased connections and data demand. This should materialise in increased capital and remediation activities to ensure that the network can manage the ever increasing workload.

SSM should also benefit from Telstra announcing recently that they will bring forward $500m of additional capex in the 2020 calendar year. This expenditure will be deployed to increase capacity as well as accelerate the roll out of their 5G network. We anticipate that Optus and Vodafone are likely to invest aggressively in their networks so as to stay competitive against Telstra.

SSM customers in the utilities sector are deemed essential services providers. As such, we do not foresee any issues when it comes to SSM completing their work orders. In fact, unlike many ASX listed companies that have provided trading updates, withdrawn guidance and cancelled their dividends, SSM has been very quiet since February and has paid their dividend – a very good sign in our mind.


Source: SSM company filings
We are attracted to the business not only because of industry tailwinds but also a robust balance sheet in a net cash position, $1bn in revenue forecast for FY20 and an estimated $115m in EBITDA. The company has a long history of generating significant free cash flow. In FY20, this should translate to about 16c EPS and a 10 cents fully franked (ff) dividend, which is very attractive on the last trading price of $2.10. This places the stock on a PE multiple of 13x and a dividend yield of 4.8% ff. We value SSM at $2.80.
Note:  After this piece was published (20 May 2020) SSM provided a market update at 2.27pm on 21 May 2020. SSM updated the market of EBITDA guidance of $108m and strong cashflow. The company has experienced some delays on work with certain customers due to the lockdowns but nothing material that changes our medium- to long-term thesis.

Disclaimer: SSM is held in the TAMIM Australia All Cap and Small Cap Income portfolios.

Talking 2 Top Telcos | Part 1

This week we look at the telco sector and how it is benefiting from a surge in demand due to the shift to working and staying at home. We believe the demand for faster connectivity will continue for the foreseeable future regardless of how the Covid-19 situation unfolds. We currently see good value in two companies servicing the sector. Read on to find out more.

Authors: Ron Shamgar

Over the last few weeks we have spoken to several telcos and service providers and the common theme so far is an increase in demand for faster internet, higher bandwidth and business services such as teleconferencing and number porting. With a wide range of ASX stocks to choose from, we have invested in a couple of stocks that are both highly profitable, cashed up and on an upgrade cycle. This week we discuss one of them.

Uniti Wireless (UWL.ASX) is a provider of telecommunications services specialising in fixed wireless, fibre and telco services to both consumers and small/medium sized businesses. UWL competes directly with the NBN and wholesales its fibre network to internet service providers in residential multi dwelling buildings and housing estates. This division of the company generates 55% of group revenues, has very high margins and is cash generative.

 

Source: Company filings
UWL also provides businesses with connectivity solutions such as 1300 numbers, number porting and phone PBX (Private Branch Exchange, a private telephone network used within a company or organisation) hosting solutions. This division is approximately 45% of group revenues and, although it operates in a more competitive part of the telco market, we believe it will continue to grow organically and through acquisitions.

Source: Company filings

Part of the appeal of UWL is the high quality senior management team and a board of directors with extensive experience in the industry. For instance, CEO Michael Simmons has over 30 years’ experience and was the CEO of both SP Telemedia and Vocus. Similarly, director Vaughan Bowen was the founder of M2 Group which was established 20 years ago and eventually acquired by Vocus. Directors have been continuously buying shares on market and in placements. 

We view UWL as a sector consolidator. The company has undergone a series of acquisitions since listing last year and will continue to be acquisitive going forward. The company has over $36m of net cash to deploy. So far management has shown that acquired businesses are growing ahead of original expectations.

Source: Company filings

The company has upgraded profits twice this financial year so far while most other companies have been withdrawing their guidance. At the last quarterly update in April, UWL notes the following key developments:

  • March 2020 run-rate EBITDA is tracking above the internal forecasts that underpinned the prior upgraded guidance released in February 2020.

  • All three UWL business units performed above forecast in the March quarter, including revenue, earnings and cash collections.

  • Increased levels of work-from-home, online learning and domestic internet consumption due to Covid-19 have strengthened underlying demand for UWL’s superfast fibre-to-the-premises (FTTP) services.

  • UWL’s fibre infrastructure business delivered a record number of net new FTTP connections in March 2020.

Source: Company filings

We estimate UWL will earn over $80m of revenues and about $45m of EBITDA in FY21. The sector is currently trading on EV/EBITDA of close to 10x. UWL is on 9.5x while growing at significantly higher rates and, unlike many of its peers, is debt free. We believe UWL deserves a premium and we value the stock at about the $1.80 level.

Disclaimer: UWL is held in the TAMIM Australia All Cap portfolios.

10 Principles to Invest By

We have always said that it is important to take time and revisit the basics every now and then. Living and breathing the markets day in, day out can let us lose sight of these basics, not seeing the forest for the trees if you will. It is often the simplest things that remain consistent for a longer time horizon. To crystallise things a little, we would like to go back and explain some things to our 21 year old selves with particular reference to some rules of thumb about how to think about finances and financial independence. 
​These principles are linked, interwoven and affect one another. The markets are complex organisms and we can’t expect to apply sweeping statements that are independent and stand alone. The basics are exactly that, the basics. They can be built upon and complicated immeasurably.

Principle 1 – High Return = High Risk

The markets are a function of risk, though we often forget this in the world we live in given the unconventional policy shenanigans that have somewhat flipped this on its head . The key is to understand the amount of risk taken and the expected return. The strongest investments (and investors) are those that maximise expected return and systematically reduce risk. For example, if two investments, A and B, have the same expected return, the key will be determining which has a lower risk profile. Investment is an art as much as it is a science, hence this might be a question of belief as much as it is about quantitative analysis.

Risk can also be understood as volatility and that is something that we have to learn to live with. There are certainly times at which the markets can be brutal and, as Charlie Munger says, a 50% drawdown is simply the price of admission. However, keep perspective and remember that, with a few notable exceptions like the Great Depression, the markets have been excessively kind over the past century and a bit. The way to think about volatility is time frame more than anything else. If you are looking at a time horizon of decades (be it talking about intergenerational wealth or those still in the workforce) as opposed to years then volatility and forgoing returns now for the future is not necessarily all that bad. Time in the market, not timing the market. Which brings us to our next point….


Principle 2 – Rule of 72

The Power of Compounding

Einstein called compounding the eighth wonder of the world and nowhere is this more evident than in the “Rule of 72”, used to determine how long it will take for money to double. It is a simple principle, annualised return of 7.2% means that it will take ten years for money to double. Seems rather obvious but looking at your universe in this manner allows you to be more disciplined and the perspective lets us know that there is no need to be in too much of a hurry. Using the same 7.2% return over forty years, 100,000 grows to 1,600,000 assuming that there are no additional investments.

This just gets better with regular contributions, potentially the best way to build wealth over the long haul. It also goes a long way to minimizing what we call sequencing risk, going all in at once and, in the event of sell-off, spending valuable time recovering is a rather unexceptional outcome. Automatic investments allow you to do dollar cost averaging, a fantastic way to maintain a disciplined approach to investing and controlling the emotional aspects associated with volatility.

For those of you that are a little more aggressive and want to go beyond the basics, have a rules based system whereby every percentage drawdown in the market gets you to buy cumulatively more and vice versa. Basically making sure that the amount of “aggression” is a direct and inverse correlation with market sentiment.



Principle 3 – Buy Insurance

Hope for the best, plan for the worst
Whether you’re investing or you’re planning for your broader personal finances, it is crucial to understand that the only certainty in life is uncertainty. Unfortunately, the only certainty in the markets is that the markets hate uncertainty. We were reminded of this the hard way recently given the marked sell-off. We won’t be doing that again. Buying contents insurance doesn’t mean that you want to have a burglary or a fire accident but it makes sense to spread risk anyway.  Taking out protection on your portfolio may cost you 1% in returns in an “average” year but could save you many times that in the one-off major drawdowns.


Principle 4 – Don’t Borrow (If you can’t repay)

Leverage can be the ninth wonder since it can amplify returns. But debt should only be productive, using it for tactical purposes when it comes to investments or for making property investments is quite different from borrowing for the sake of borrowing. Always assume the worst. For example, if making a property investment what might happen if all of a sudden your tenancies are cut in half or interest rates double? Again, always prepare for the worst and put capital to work like it is a rarity, as though you’re constantly in distress, even when it is freely available.

For equities investors, leverage can be a double-edged sword and the long-term benefits and drawbacks have more to do with emotional stability than about the actual numbers. For most of us (and this author in particular), if the first use of margin calls and leverage was a positive experience then the likelihood of staying in the game and developing bad habits is much easier. On the flipside if it is bad, then you might be irrationally risk averse and gun-shy.

Human beings are fundamentally motivated by two things, fear and greed. At their most base level these are literally just survival instincts, avoid things that will hurt us and acquire as much as we can of the things that make life/survival easier (i.e. food/shelter or the means to acquire them, also known as wealth?). Even the most stringent and genuinely altruistic ESG investor is simply motivated by the fear of what kind of world they think they will have to live in down the line given the current course, that long-term (unselfish) fear is simply outweighing short-term greed.  The key is exactly that, finding a balance between the two. It was also very early on that this author learnt the downside of leverage too. If, instead of the -25% decline, you can stomach a -50% drop in a perfectly reasonable portfolio due to unforeseen events, such as those that have recently taken place (assuming a 2x leveraged portfolio), then you will be fine and recover over the long-term. If not, then steady as she goes and don’t bother.

The key here being don’t take risks on what you can’t afford to lose and always plan on the premise that what you borrow has the potential to go to zero and work around that. Plainly, only use leverage for a small proportion of your portfolio.

 

Principle 5 – Quit Procrastinating!

This one is probably the hardest. We constantly get overloaded with information, cognitive biases and different views on any number of markets and stocks. On a subconscious level, this overload might be an excuse for us to procrastinate and not make decisions. If you decided that you wanted to avail yourself of every possible bit of information and opinion on Apple stock before making any decision to buy then you would probably die never having logged on to your trading platform, let alone held it. There is simply too much information to do so. That is an extreme and hypothetical example (and that is why entire companies exist to distill some of that information) but it illustrates the point. Don’t get paralyzed by information overload.

Budget right, figure out your goals, the parameters within which you wish to achieve them and, as Nike says, just do it. The markets never have certainty, you can’t expect it from them, they are a function of probabilities. Develop a view, use your judgement and rationale and follow through with it. Be nimble if things have changed and willing to accept when (notice we didn’t say if) you get it wrong. In the immortal words of television survivalist Bear Grylls, “Improvise, adapt, overcome.” (We’re more paying attention to the “adapt, overcome” part here, feel free to improvise within your set parameters though.)


​Yes, we might lose, but that’s life. Diversification and action is better than procrastination. Don’t get us wrong, we’re not saying be aggressive all the time but understand that even inaction is conversely an action in and of itself. If you have actively made the decision based on LOGIC that it isn’t a particularly good time, ask yourself the question why? And do so with the idea that you’re giving a presentation to a room full of so called financial experts who will question every assumption and everything you say. If you can’t do it then go back to the drawing board.

Time is money! The saying exists for a reason.

Principle 6 – Diversification is Vital

Remember Principle 1 about risk? Diversification is central to managing risk over a long-term time horizon. The key to diversification is managing, over the short-run, volatility risk and, over the long-run, market risk. Volatility risk is self-explanatory but market risk is the potential for a permanent loss in investment and this is exceptionally important on a long-term horizon. Though a full-time investor can afford to be a lot more concentrated given that they are constantly tracking underlying investments but for most of you that actually have a life to be lived, this is crucial. Remember that some of the top companies even a few decades ago, like Kodak, are no longer market darlings. So, no matter how good you think companies are at the moment, there is a potential over the long-term for risk to accrue as markets change and new technologies eat away at incumbents, the point being though the market might be a “voting machine in the short-run over the long-run it is a weighing machine” stay diversified and take move the weights. The obvious lesson here is stay attentive and make adjustments as markets and trends change but we are talking about diversification. There are those in the TAMIM office that believe you should only invest in companies that you are comfortable holding for ten, twenty or even thirty-plus years and this is where diversification becomes important. If Company X goes to zero and is one of ten (evenly weighted) stocks you own then the pain is significantly worse than if it were one of thirty.

However, that said, the marginal benefits of adding additional investments decreases as the numbers get larger and the costs become greater, taking us back to the risk/reward trade-off. If you want to shore up your risk profile then you are going to have to sacrifice some reward. The optimal is probably between 15-30 different strategies or allocations with the older you are, the more likely you are to go towards the higher number.

Principle 7 – Ask Questions

This is true  life in general, not only for investing. It is what makes us human and what distinguishes our species. Asking why?

Everytime you make a new investment or think through an opportunity, keep asking why until it drives you quite literally mad. Just as a child who constantly questions, ask your investment managers why they do certain things and why they make their decisions, ask your local candidate on what your tax money is being spent. Questioning every assumption you’ve made and your entire belief system will make you not only a better investor but a better citizen (within reason, we don’t want hundreds of people spiraling into an existential crisis having read this).

For the more enterprising amongst you, please feel free to raise a ruckus if you go to AGMs, it might be worthwhile every now and then to have management realize that they are merely custodians. We are the owners, thank you sir!


Principle 8 – Emergency Cash Fund

We live in a lucky country, but also a country with some of the highest levels of household debt in the developed world (120% of GDP and likely to go higher). The low interest rate environment can make this seem painful but it is also true that we haven’t had excess amounts of inflation, it might therefore make sense to keep a certain portion of overall wealth in cash (no, not because you’re procrastinating!) for living expenses. The rule of thumb would be at least three months income for below 35s and for every five years after that add on another three months.

Principle 9 – Keep  Track of Mega-trends & Mega-themes When Investing for the Long Term

This calls back to the point made in Principle 6 about staying attentive and adjusting. The best way to illustrate this principle might be to give examples. Some thematics that we currently recognise are the following:

  • Slower Economic Growth across the West.
  • Demographic Shifts: As the population across the West and even economies like China change, we will see marked shifts in both the spending patterns and stresses on the economy. Understand how this might impact healthcare, inflation, government pension liabilities, productivity growth etc.
  • Artificial Intelligence: This is arguably the most important over the coming decades. This is seen as having implications across transportation (driverless cars), financial services and retail (dislocations across frontline sectors). Most companies, including tech stocks, are at the forefront of making the requisite investments. But understand that in a dynamic world, there is always the potential for left-field events such as a new entrant with an innovative product gaining market dominance quickly.
  • Fragile Social Programs & Increased Income Inequality: As we headed into the most recent crisis, we were already encumbered by large amounts of government debt and fiscal liabilities, this is likely to get worse as structural unemployment and technological advancement puts downward pressure on wage growth leading to further income inequality. This has massive implications for investors. On the surface level, ask yourself questions like how this impacts luxury goods? Or gambling? But on a deeper level, this places immense uncertainty around the policy environment and the possibility of future inflation (governments have been known to try and inflate away the value of debt) and populism.

One does want to be careful with these mega-trends though. There will always be massive winners from these mega-trends but they are not easy to pick, let alone pick early on.  Just look at one of the dominant mega trends of this millennium, social media. Back in 2006, who would have picked Facebook to so comprehensively and completely eviscerate MySpace? MySpace overtook Google as the most visited website in the US in June 2006, Facebook took over worldwide in April 2008 (May 2009 for the US). And yes, MySpace does still exist. The trend is more mature now but players are still coming, going and being acquired by the incumbents. Think Vine, Snapchat and now TikTok (a lot of those words will mean nothing to those that aren’t at the younger end of their adult lives or are without children). The point here being that picking the ultimate winner in these mega-trends is difficult, it is more interesting to think about how these mega-trends will support or detract from companies that are also not directly involved. Oversimplifying it a bit and looking at something that is playing out in the world today, don’t try to pick the electric car manufacturer that will ultimately be the big winner, pick the company that will be providing the components to half the players for the batteries, the semiconductor metrology manufacturer for the tech companies etc.

Simply put, simplify some of the mega-trends you might see, overlay it with your portfolio and try to get creative around how your portfolio behaves as those mega-trends play out. Make sure you are comfortable within this context.

Principle 10 : Minimise Taxes

First of all, duh. The less you give up in taxes, the more you end up with in your pocket. Following on from compounding, minimising the amount of taxes can make a marked difference in the long-term wealth of individuals and their families. In Australia, it is as simple as things like putting capital growth assets within the superannuation environment and utilising franking credits appropriately. Using credits to defer, reduce or “avoid” income taxes are things that have to be done in a disciplined manner.

With that being said, remember to not use tax incentives to make investment decisions, only the vehicles within which those investments sit. “I’m not selling because I don’t want to pay capital gains tax” is one of the most frustrating pieces of logic we hear all too often. First of all, you’re paying those taxes because you have done well, that is a good thing. More importantly, refusing to sell for this reason when you KNOW there are better companies/opportunities out there to allocate to doesn’t make sense. Taking the short term hit to set yourself up for better long-term growth just seems like the prudent course of action for a genuine long-term investor. Unless you trust your policy makers so much that you believe the status quo will be kept indefinitely. As last year has shown, remember the debate around franking? Keep the purity of investment and make them on their own merits, after which you can undertake the exercise of tax minimisation.

2019 A Surprisingly Good Year for Risk Assets: 2020 Outlook

Robert Swift takes a brief look at the year that was 2019 and casts his eye toward 2020. What should we expect to see and where might we find risk appropriate returns?

 

Equity returns were strong in 2019 with major markets rising between 25 – 30% in US$ terms. This was despite an aura of despair regarding the strength of the global economy at the start of the year. Growth beat Value again and Large beat Small by a little bit.

In major markets the composition of returns was mostly comprised of price/earnings multiple expansion and negligible profits growth. In the United States a total return of 28.8% comprised 1.1% profits growth, 1.8% dividends with the balance provided by an expanded valuation taking the prospective P/E multiple to 18.5x for 2020. Market expectations for 10% profits growth in the United States in 2020 are likely to be downgraded to low single digits. China was one of the few markets where earnings and dividends generated the entire return of 16.8% and the earnings multiple contracted. China on a prospective P/E of 12.1x and Asia as a whole, on 14.4x offer a more sustainable mix of profits and dividends to generate returns in 2020. We are likely to find attractive stocks in these markets in 2020. We especially like smaller companies.

By the way, we recommend, again, that investors do not use GDP forecasts to predict equity returns, nor try to frequently trade asset class exposure up and down.

Despite or because of, such a strong year, we expect 2020 to be less buoyant. With more than a third of the world’s sovereign bond market providing negative yields, the relationships between equities and bonds, and discount rates for profit and dividend growth, remain anything but ‘normal’. In 2020 focus on decent balance sheets and be wary of locking your money away in illiquid assets. The WeWork/Softbank saga and the Woodford Investments fiasco in the UK show that the real risk of illiquid assets should not be calculated based on their price volatility; the true risk of illiquid assets is MUCH higher than liquid assets.

At some point the experiment of zero interest rates for all (ZIRP) will come to an end and someone will be found to be ‘swimming naked’. Debts have risen enormously and not all of these can be honoured or repaid. At this time illiquid assets will suddenly not look so good. Bear in mind just what a large percentage of USA IPOs that are loss making when they list. This is rather strange and reflects very high-risk tolerance by investors for unproven business models. The era of ZIRP has created hidden investment traps for everyone. We use Bucephalus based in Hong Kong to help us identify these.

We believe 2019 was the start of a multi-year re-appraisal of Japan and its problems. They are NOT the same as the problems in the Anglo Saxon West even though the media uses the phrase ‘turning Japanese’ to describe all struggling economies. Japan’s low nominal GDP is actually caused by poor demographics and not poor productivity from labour and capital investment. Australia has the reverse problem. Japan has adopted, quietly, a more thoughtful approach to immigration. Australia has not yet adopted a more thoughtful approach to total factor productivity. Japan’s low nominal GDP growth is irrelevant for the risk premium to be placed on Japanese corporate profits. Japan’s risk premium should be lower – in other words the market should be higher. It will get there.

If the West is “turning Japanese” it is only to the extent that zero interest rates have prevented the necessary clear out of bad capital allocation decisions – Japan had a similar problem for many years with the so called ‘convoy system’ preventing bad companies from going to the wall, or with shareholders not changing management. This attitude looks like changing and much M&A and corporate re-structuring is probably going to continue in Japan as a consequence. As for Europe and its “extend and pretend” attitude to their banking system? It is not going to end well. In that regard they are ‘turning Japanese’; just as Japan changes for the better.

Brexit is now likely to happen in some form or other and the withdrawal (probably reduction) of UK net contributions and the likely shrinking of its trade deficit (removing a much-needed source of demand for the Rest of Europe) may wake up policy makers in the EU? Ironically the EU could be worth joining if it reforms; but it will only reform if the UK leaves. This is a sort of reverse Groucho Marx situation – “I would want to join a club I had just left”?

We invested more in the UK before the election but will wait to see the exit terms, and the EU response, before we consider reducing a large underweight in Europe.

Hong Kong protests are understandable and with luck there will be pressure brought to bear on China to be more ‘democratic’ in its treatment of its outer regions. China is now more reliant on inward capital and global investors can make a difference. We can’t sign off without making the remark that if ESG is going to be effective and not just a ‘parroted phrase’, then much more work needs to be done to define what spheres it reasonably influences; how to measure success or change as a result of its implementation, and whether there can be one universally agreed set of principles. For example, even if China agrees to change as a result of global investor pressure (led by everyone’s most hated administration, the USA!), up pops India (everyone’s favourite emerging market economy but not ours) with its own brand of discrimination which should actually be triggering investment sanctions if ESG is to be more than ‘words’. Don’t get us started on Westpac.

Maybe 2020 is the year that ESG becomes more than a box ticking exercise? We hope so. We don’t manage (yet?) enough assets to make a real difference but do let companies know if we are unhappy with their Governance which we continue to believe is the root of all capital allocation decisions.

Best of luck for 2020 in your investing and we wish to thank everyone with whom we have had contact in 2019 for their interest. Don’t hesitate to get in touch if you wish to discuss any issue with us.