Is the ASX Undervalued? What Investors Should Know

Is the ASX Undervalued? What Investors Should Know

13 Feb, 2025 | Market Insight

Written by Ron Shamgar

Ron Shamgar, Head of Australian Equities and portfolio manager for the TAMIM Australia All Cap portfolio, shares his market insights on the latest developments shaping the investment landscape.

The first month of the year has provided investors with a strong start, buoyed by optimism surrounding the incoming Trump administration and its pro-business policies. This sentiment has translated into solid equity performance, particularly in the U.S. markets, where the S&P 500 ended the month on a strong note. Historically, when the index rises by more than 2% in January, the year tends to deliver positive results. Since 1951, such instances have led to an average annual return of 18.4%, with markets finishing higher 88% of the time. If history is any guide, this is an encouraging sign for investors.

Australian Market Outlook

Closer to home, Australian consumer sentiment is showing signs of improvement, though it remains below historical norms. Most economists are forecasting interest rate cuts in either February or March, a move that we believe would be highly supportive of local equity markets. Small and mid-cap stocks, in particular, stand to benefit from a lower rate environment, as cheaper capital fuels business expansion and investor appetite for growth opportunities.

Are Markets Overvalued? A Deeper Look

One question that continues to dominate investor discussions is whether current market valuations are stretched. The U.S. market, particularly the ten largest stocks, does appear to be trading at elevated price-to-earnings (PE) multiples. Drawing parallels to the dot-com boom, the highest-weighted stocks today exhibit high PE ratios similar to those seen during the internet bubble. However, an important distinction is that today’s market leaders generate significantly higher earnings and enjoy strong competitive moats, making them more fundamentally sound than their late-1990s counterparts.

Furthermore, while the ten largest U.S. stocks are trading at elevated valuations, the broader market tells a different story. The remaining 490 stocks in the S&P 500 are trading at PE ratios below the long-term market average, which starkly contrasts with the dot-com era when high valuations were widespread across the index.

A Global Perspective

Looking beyond the U.S., valuation concerns appear less pronounced. Many global markets do not have the same concentration of high-growth technology companies, which has kept their PE ratios in check. Unlike the early 2000s, when global equities also experienced high valuations during the internet boom, today’s overvaluation concerns seem largely confined to a select few U.S. stocks.

This suggests that any potential correction in these high-growth names may not necessarily have broad-based repercussions across global equity markets. Instead, a sector-specific pullback could present opportunities for investors in other areas of the market.

Sector Insights: Opportunities and Risks

Breaking it down by sector, we are seeing particular strength in industrials, energy, and materials. Infrastructure and renewable energy investments continue to attract capital, while the mining sector benefits from sustained demand for commodities.

Technology remains a key driver of global markets, but its high valuations necessitate careful stock selection. While AI and cloud computing companies continue to gain traction, concerns over regulatory scrutiny and market saturation pose risks that investors must navigate.

Financials are another area to watch closely. With potential rate cuts on the horizon, banks may face margin compression, but this could also lead to increased lending activity, benefiting economic growth in the long run.

The TAMIM Takeaway 

Now that we are in February, our focus turns to upcoming economic data releases and corporate earnings season, which will provide key insights into market conditions and potential investment opportunities. In our weekly investment newsletter, we provide a detailed commentary on recent updates, reflecting our positioning in this evolving environment.

We look forward to sharing more insights in our next monthly report following the February results season. Until then, we continue to monitor developments closely and remain committed to identifying value in a dynamic market landscape.