5 Predictions for 2023 (& How We Did Predicting 2022)14/12/2022 We have arrived at our final article of 2022, and, as usual, we thought it would be interesting to revisit our predictions for the past year and come up with a few more heading into 2023.
First, in terms of our predictions for 2022, we admit like many in the market this year, our track record here could have been better. But as with many things in life, it pays to reflect.
Prediction 1: Despite talk of monetary policy normalisation, this will not occur. QE moderates somewhat.This is perhaps the biggest left-of-field event since the advent of Covid, which we did not foresee given the significantly higher global debt burden. To put some context, while the current target rate of 4.25%-4.5% at the time of writing is not necessarily high by historical standards, it represents the fastest and highest proportionality rise in history.
We got this completely wrong (but lets see how long rates can be maintained at these levels). We find surprising the relatively benign economic landscape for emerging markets, given the implications for the dollar index. That is, global growth has been relatively resilient, especially compared to similar periods, with GDP growth still on track to print 2.7% for 22′.Score: 0/1
Prediction 2: Equities continue to outperform despite the “easy” returns being close to impossible.This one depends on how you look at it. When putting this forward, our thesis was related to our first prediction on central bank policy. That is, negative real yields will effectively mean that equities as an asset class would continue to remain attractive in relation to fixed income and cash. We were correct on the point of negative real yields, but we did go wrong: the rise in CPI and the aggressiveness of central bank policy would create an environment with minimal cover. Cash was perhaps the best-performing asset class this year, with the fixed-income and global equities markets effectively seeing a rout. That is, the return on cash in real terms was less negative than the other asset classes (i.e. we are assuming here that our investment horizon is made solely of three potential allocations, Fixed Income, Cash and Equities). Score: 0.5/1
Prediction 3: Oil continues to rebound and could very well hit 100 USD/barrelOur prediction on this point was reasonable in that both Brent and WTI continued their upward trajectory for much of the year, crossing the 100 USD mark to stay above that level for more than a quarter. However, we posit that much of that action was the Russia-Ukraine war rather than our central thesis around supply constraints.
The question remains whether our thesis around supply was what drove the price higher or trading patterns following the invasion.Score: 1/1
Prediction 4: Iron ore continues to rebound back above 180 USD/TThis is another call we could have done better with, at least insofar as pricing. Our thesis was that the historical centrality of Chinese steel production to the spot price would disentangle substantially this year, driven primarily by alternative markets for the seaborne market. That is, higher energy prices (i.e. prediction 3) would create an impetus for a greater focus on the renewables sector in the developed world.
What we did see, however, was quite the opposite. The price rises would be substantial enough, and central bank policy was hawkish enough to slow down capital flows and alternative steel production. We also did not see the sheer scale of irrationality regarding the Covid-0 policy undertaken by Beijing, which they have quickly backtracked on after protests. If recent price action after the easing of lockdown restrictions in China is anything to go by, Iron Ore remains a China story for the foreseeable future.Score: 0.25/1
Prediction 5: The ASX and Asian Indices will be the better performersAgain, this is one prediction that we got partially right. We are referring to the broader MSCI Asia (both Ex and including Japan), which has held up relatively well compared to the developed counterparts. We were partially aware that China would be a drag, and we were rather bullish on South East Asia. On the latter point, this prediction was rather prescient given that some of the best-performing indices were Vietnam and emerging markets in South East Asia. In India, we were wrong, with our prediction being that it was partially high, the SENSEX getting higher at the time of writing (YTD +5.9%). On the question of the ASX, our prediction relied on a higher price level across the commodities complex, but this proved to be a little more complicated than expected. Again the story has been China (and related Iron Ore spot prices), the drag from broader commodities price stagnation and multiple compression. Score: 0.5/1 With that somewhat less than stellar fair grade of 2.25/5, we continue on our fools errand and make five more predictions for 23′.
TAMIM top 5 predictions for 2023:Prediction 1: The Fed, along with developed central banks, ease on the hiking cycle.
At the cost of sounding insane (i.e. doing the same thing repeatedly and expecting a different result), we again predict central bank policy. We agree with the bond market this time (our previous stance being contrarian) that the Fed will ease on its speed of rate hikes with a pivot towards the backend of Q1 with the target stabilising at 5%.
The question for Australia is similar, with the RBA arguably caught in a much more tenuous situation given the extent of household debt in the country. There are two primary questions to look out for, the increase in CPI at least M-o-M continues to average down. Secondly, wage growth.Assuming the current run-rate (i.e. inflation coming in at 0.1% for November, down from 0.4% in October), we should see it hitting a more manageable 4% p.a. in the US by the end of Q1 next year. On the question of wage growth, we state with some degree of conviction that these pressures will ease despite the current IR reform in this country. Our rationale is twofold: the shockingly low degree of union participation and the implications for collective action and the opening up of borders after close to two years in the developed world (i.e. immigration). On the former point of union membership, the latest statistics show that union membership has declined to the lowest on record (12.5% of employees in Aus). That being said, the case for the Eurozone may be markedly different. The ECB has to deal with a somewhat complex set of economic factors, including divergent inflation rates across its jurisdiction and an asymmetric relationship between north and south (i.e. Germany and the frugal north vs. the likes of Italy, Greece etc.) They have been a rather prominent laggard in raising rates and thus may also be a laggard in normalising policy. Given the substantial overreliance on Russia, the energy cost is also not particularly helpful.
Prediction 2: Equities Outperform over the year, but fixed income could see substantial short-term opportunitiesClosely related to our prediction of central bank pivot, we categorically stick to our conviction of equities as an asset class outperforming. Our contention remains that the easy returns that characterised the past decade and a half in the form of multiple expansions are well behind us. We make the case that the coming cycle will be one for the stockpicker with at least a nominal discount rate coming into the equation (as opposed to the perverse 0 we have gotten so used to and done well out of). Sector-wise, goods will outperform services in developed economies, and here we speak about consumer staples, industrials and the needs to have (enabled substantially by government policy).
Despite the reopening of China, we continue to be bearish on that particular government, given a substantially higher probability of political instability (we have not said this about China in nearly five decades). China will, in our view, effectively go through its second wave, and the numbers will be substantial. The key to watch for the Australian investor is how big the stimulus from Beijing is to support growth targets. The question of whether there will be support is predetermined.On the question of fixed income, a spectacular rout in 2022 left many investors reeling and asking whether it may be more rational to take on equities exposure. If the downside for investment grade is in the double digits, we think the pricing looks relatively attractive within a central bank pivot across the developed world. This creates substantial upside and, for the discerning investor, the potential for an outsized risk-reward proposition. Although, we remain bearish over the long run, given the increased risk of financial repression.
Prediction 3: Oil Stabilises at around $90 USD/ppbThe bears have come out regarding the price of black gold given the prospects of a recession in 23′. Our thesis remains for an elevated price level given the supply issues we previously elaborated upon for close to 2 years. Aside from this, there are three more factors to watch for here:
As it currently stands, even during a global recession, the supply metrics are such that we will continue to see elevated pricing.
Prediction 4: Gold will have some much-needed reprieveFirstly, what a year for the yellow metal. Like the rest of the market, we have been left scratching our heads regarding the price action. While we have never believed that it offered a particularly great hedge against inflation, especially when compared to base metals such as copper, we have always been consistent in our view that it does offer a hedge against uncertainty. On the latter point, we saw the advent of a war that could have quickly escalated into one between two nuclear powers, the continued lockdown of the second-largest economy on the planet, yet the pricing was less than interesting. To date, two legitimate explanations stick; the first is the idea of gold offering an alternative as a store of value. Indeed, this does have some credence given the substantial rise from its lows of $1627 USD per ounce to $1807 USD. The second is that rising treasury yields have effectively placed a lid on the non-yielding metal. The latter point is the most significant headwind for the yellow metal, and a significant net buyer in the form of the Russian central bank has been taken offline following sanctions. Thus, if we see, as is our base case, the Fed pivot and thus the dollar index start to taper a little, this should by extension, imply support for the shiny metal. That is, the uncertainty remains while the headwind could turn into a tailwind (i.e. a pivot could also imply negative real yields).
Prediction 5: Commodities stabilise, and Iron Ore comes back into the vogue with a price targetWe begin with the obvious, which is Chinese steel production. Our base case remains that as the Covid-0 policy is rewound, we should see steel production tick up, assuming conservative 2018 levels (in terms of output) and accounting for inflation. Since then, we have made the base case of $150 USD per tonne. Though our conviction in terms of timing is substantially less than may otherwise be the case within the context of a significant fall in global steel demand, at least in the short-run, as recession fears take effect. We are also somewhat blind regarding our numbers around current stockpiles, Beijing having previously successfully used measures to curb demand in early 22′.
Over the long run, however, we remain convinced that the long-term cycle for Iron Ore (FE 63.5%) should be around the $200 USD/T to $250 USD/T mark. We define the long-term cycle here as anything above three years. As for the broader commodities complex, headwinds associated with global growth concerns are in our view, overdone. Even in the shortrun given the substantial supply constraints and the current pipeline of infrastructure built out both stateside and in major economies, including the EU (i.e. the market, it seems has already forgotten some of the already earmarked projects in the Inflation Reduction Act as well as the CHIPS & Science Act).
|
5 Predictions for 2023 (& How We Did Predicting 2022)
5 Predictions for 2023 (& How We Did Predicting 2022)
Written by